I compared these five men’s training shoes by how their cushioning, upper construction, outsole, and stated fit serve different kinds of training. The Under Armour Charged Commit Trainer 5 is my leading general-purpose pick for its full-length cushioning and flexible rubber outsole. For a more structured shoe that can pull double duty for everyday wear, the New Balance 608 V5 offers a suede upper and impact-absorbing heel. The Under Armour Charged Edge in 4E is the clearest choice for shoppers who need extra-wide sizing.
Get beauty and skincare favorites delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
The tradeoff is between flex and cushioning on one side and structured support on the other. The Commit models are built around mesh and Charged Cushioning, while the 608 V5 leans into a sturdier leather build. The two Charged Edge listings share a model name and core design, but one explicitly provides 4E sizing; I rank them separately because width can decide whether a shoe is wearable. I focus on the listed features, not claims of personal testing, and point out where the supplied details leave questions unanswered.
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- Best general-purpose training option: The Charged Commit Trainer 5 pairs full-length Charged Cushioning with flex grooves and a rubber outsole.
- Best for structured support and daily wear: The New Balance 608 V5 uses a suede leather upper and ABZORB heel cushioning, but may need a break-in period.
- Best for wider feet: The Charged Edge listing with 4E extra-wide sizing is the only option here with a specifically stated wide fit.
- Best lower-offset alternative: The Commit Trainer 5 lists a 6 mm offset, compared with 8 mm on the Commit Trainer 4.
- What to weigh before choosing: Mesh models favor breathability and flexibility, while the 608 V5’s leather upper favors a more substantial, structured feel.
| Under Armour Charged Commit Trainer 5 | ![]() | Best Overall | Upper: Breathable mesh with leather overlays | Midsole: Full-length Charged Cushioning | Outsole: Full rubber with side wrap | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| New Balance Men’s 608 V5 Casual Comfort Cross Trainer | ![]() | Best for Structured Support and All-Day Wear | Upper: Suede leather | Cushioning: ABZORB heel crash pad | Midsole: EVA foam | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Under Armour Men’s Charged Edge Shoes | ![]() | Best for Extra-Wide Feet | Sizing: 4E extra wide | Upper: Breathable mesh with leather and synthetic overlays | Sockliner: Dual-layer Ortholite | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Under Armour Men’s Charged Edge Shoes | ![]() | Best for Pivot-Friendly Grip | Upper: Breathable mesh with leather and synthetic overlays | Midsole: Charged Cushioning | Sockliner: Dual-layer Ortholite | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Under Armour Men’s Charged Commit Trainer 4 Training Shoes | ![]() | Best for a Specified Weight and Classic Cushioning | Weight: 11.92 oz | Offset: 8 mm | Upper: Lightweight mesh with textured overlays | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| training shoes for men | Upper | Midsole | Outsole | Origin |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Under Armour Charged Commit Tr | Breathable mesh with leather overlays | Full-length Charged Cushioning | Full rubber with side wrap | Imported |
| New Balance Men’s 608 V5 Casua | Suede leather | EVA foam | Rubber; slip-resistant | Imported |
| Under Armour Men’s Charged Edg | Breathable mesh with leather and synthetic overlays | Charged Cushioning compression-molded foam | Full rubber with pivot and traction pattern | Imported |
| Under Armour Men’s Charged Edg | Breathable mesh with leather and synthetic overlays | Charged Cushioning | Full rubber with strategic traction patterns | Imported |
| Under Armour Men’s Charged Com | Lightweight mesh with textured overlays | Charged Cushioning | Rubber with flex grooves | Made in the USA or imported |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Under Armour Charged Commit Trainer 5
The Charged Commit Trainer 5 is my strongest pick for someone who wants one shoe for general gym sessions and movement-based training. Its full-length Charged Cushioning gives the midsole a clear role across the whole foot, while the mesh upper and leather overlays balance airflow with added structure. Flex grooves and a full rubber outsole add flexibility and ground contact, making this a more rounded training package than the more casual-feeling 608 V5.
Its listed 6 mm offset is lower than the Commit Trainer 4’s 8 mm, a useful distinction for buyers comparing the two versions. That number alone cannot predict fit or workout performance, but it gives shoppers a concrete spec difference. The tradeoff is that this listing does not state a weight or cushioning details beyond Charged Cushioning, so buyers who prioritize a known weight or a more substantial leather upper have less information than they do with the Commit 4 or New Balance 608 V5. It is a practical all-rounder, not a specialized shoe for a particular lifting or running style.
Pros:- Full-length Charged Cushioning midsole
- Breathable mesh with leather overlays
- Rubber outsole with flex grooves and side wrap
- Listed 6 mm offset
Cons:- No shoe weight is provided in the supplied specs
- No specific width option is listed
- Less structured upper than the suede New Balance 608 V5
Best for: Men seeking a general-purpose gym trainer with full-length cushioning, a breathable upper, and a flexible rubber outsole.
Not ideal for: Shoppers who need a stated extra-wide fit, a suede upper, or a listed shoe weight before choosing.
- Upper:Breathable mesh with leather overlays
- Midsole:Full-length Charged Cushioning
- Outsole:Full rubber with side wrap
- Offset:6 mm
- Closure:Lace-up
- Outer material:Polyester
- Origin:Imported
Our verdict“I rank the Commit Trainer 5 first for its balanced combination of full-length cushioning, flexible traction, and breathable support.”
New Balance Men’s 608 V5 Casual Comfort Cross Trainer
Where the Commit models emphasize mesh, flex, and Charged Cushioning, the New Balance 608 V5 takes a more substantial approach. Its suede leather upper gives the shoe a structured feel, and the ABZORB heel crash pad is specifically positioned to absorb impact at the heel. A lightweight EVA foam midsole adds cushioning beyond that heel component, while the slip-resistant rubber outsole makes it a reasonable choice for workouts that also involve plenty of standing or walking.
This is the lineup’s clearest option for a buyer who values supportive everyday wear as much as gym use. The compromise is a less airy, less immediately flexible upper than the mesh Commit Trainer 5 or Charged Edge. Leather may also need a break-in period, so it is not the obvious choice for someone who wants a soft, flexible feel right away. I place it just behind the Commit 5 for general training because its sturdier build is a particular advantage for some buyers rather than the best match for every workout.
Pros:- Suede leather upper provides a more structured feel
- ABZORB heel cushioning absorbs impact
- EVA foam midsole adds cushioning
- Slip-resistant rubber outsole
Cons:- Leather upper may need a break-in period
- Less breathable in construction than the mesh options
- Limited color options are noted in the supplied product information
Best for: Men who want a structured cross trainer for moderate workouts, standing, and everyday wear.
Not ideal for: Shoppers who prioritize a lightweight-feeling mesh upper, immediate flexibility, or a modern low-profile training design.
- Upper:Suede leather
- Cushioning:ABZORB heel crash pad
- Midsole:EVA foam
- Outsole:Rubber; slip-resistant
- Closure:Lace-up
- Lining:Phantom Liner
- Origin:Imported
Our verdict“I recommend the 608 V5 when a supportive, structured shoe for gym use and daily wear matters more than a flexible mesh feel.”
Under Armour Men’s Charged Edge Shoes
This Charged Edge listing has one standout advantage that separates it from every other shoe here: 4E extra-wide sizing. For men who often find standard-width trainers restrictive, that fit specification may matter more than small differences in cushioning. The breathable mesh upper uses leather and synthetic overlays for added structure, while the dual-layer Ortholite sockliner and Charged Cushioning midsole provide a comfort-focused setup. A full rubber outsole has a strategic pivot and traction pattern, matching the shoe’s movement-oriented purpose.
Compared with the standard Charged Edge listing, the 4E version is the practical pick when width is the deciding factor; compared with the Commit Trainer 5, its supplied specs give more explicit detail about wide sizing and the pivot-focused outsole. The limitation is that the description does not state an offset or shoe weight, and it does not establish how the fit behaves beyond the 4E designation. Buyers with regular-width feet may be better served by the Commit 5’s clearly described full-length midsole and flex grooves, while those seeking a leather-dominant build should look at the New Balance 608 V5.
Pros:- Listed 4E extra-wide sizing
- Breathable mesh with leather and synthetic overlays
- Dual-layer Ortholite sockliner
- Rubber outsole with pivot and traction pattern
Cons:- No offset or shoe weight is listed in the supplied specs
- The 4E width may be too roomy for standard-width feet
- Workout-specific performance details are limited
Best for: Men who need extra room through the shoe and want a cushioned trainer with a rubber outsole for pivots and grip.
Not ideal for: Men who wear standard widths, want a stated offset or weight, or prefer a sturdy suede upper.
- Sizing:4E extra wide
- Upper:Breathable mesh with leather and synthetic overlays
- Sockliner:Dual-layer Ortholite
- Midsole:Charged Cushioning compression-molded foam
- Outsole:Full rubber with pivot and traction pattern
- Outer material:Polyester
- Origin:Imported
Our verdict“I would choose this Charged Edge listing first when extra-wide fit is the primary requirement.”
Under Armour Men’s Charged Edge Shoes
The standard Charged Edge shares its core comfort setup with the wide version: Charged Cushioning, a dual-layer Ortholite sockliner, and a full rubber outsole designed with strategic traction patterns. Its mesh upper includes leather and synthetic overlays to add stability without giving up the airflow associated with mesh. Among these five, it is the most directly described around pivots and grip, making it an appealing option for general workouts that include changes of direction.
I rank it below the 4E listing for buyers who specifically need extra width because no width is specified here. Against the Commit Trainer 5, it offers a named Ortholite sockliner and a traction pattern for pivots, while the Commit gives a clearer description of its full-length cushioning and flex grooves. The stated drawback is that the shoe may feel firm at first until broken in. The supplied specs also omit offset and weight, so shoppers comparing those measurements should look to the Commit Trainer 4 or 5, where offset is provided.
Pros:- Breathable mesh upper with durable overlays
- Dual-layer Ortholite sockliner
- Charged Cushioning midsole
- Full rubber outsole with strategic traction patterns
Cons:- May feel firm initially until broken in
- No width designation is provided
- Offset and weight are not listed in the supplied specs
Best for: Men seeking a mesh training shoe with a rubber outsole described for grip and pivots, in a listing without a specified extra-wide size.
Not ideal for: Men who need 4E width, want detailed weight and offset specs, or dislike a potentially firm break-in feel.
- Upper:Breathable mesh with leather and synthetic overlays
- Midsole:Charged Cushioning
- Sockliner:Dual-layer Ortholite
- Outsole:Full rubber with strategic traction patterns
- Sole material:Rubber
- Inner material:Ortholite and polyester
- Origin:Imported
Our verdict“I see the standard Charged Edge as a grip-focused alternative to the Commit 5, with less sizing detail and a possible firm break-in.”
Under Armour Men’s Charged Commit Trainer 4 Training Shoes
The Charged Commit Trainer 4 is a straightforward mesh trainer with a useful amount of detail in its listed specifications. A leather midfoot saddle adds support to the breathable upper, while Charged Cushioning and a comfort sockliner address underfoot impact and step-in feel. Its rubber outsole uses flex grooves, so it has a clear flexibility advantage over a rigid, heavily structured design. It is a sensible option for shoppers who want a familiar cushioned training setup and value having a stated weight.
That weight—11.92 oz—is also a tradeoff for buyers who favor a lighter shoe. The listed 8 mm offset differs from the Commit Trainer 5’s 6 mm, and the newer model provides a fuller description of its Charged Cushioning and outsole side wrap. Compared with the New Balance 608 V5, the Commit 4 has a more breathable mesh-led build, while the New Balance offers the more substantial suede upper. The product listing also includes a California Prop 65 warning for chromium compounds, which buyers may wish to review. I rank it fifth because the Commit 5 presents a more compelling general-purpose specification set, not because the Commit 4 lacks useful training features.
Pros:- Breathable mesh upper
- Leather midfoot saddle adds support
- Charged Cushioning and comfort sockliner
- Rubber outsole with flex grooves
Cons:- Listed weight is 11.92 oz
- 8 mm offset is higher than the Commit Trainer 5’s listed 6 mm
- Product listing carries a California Prop 65 warning for chromium compounds
Best for: Men who want a breathable, cushioned trainer with a leather midfoot support piece and a listed shoe weight.
Not ideal for: Shoppers prioritizing the lower listed offset of the Commit 5, a lighter stated weight, or a leather upper.
- Weight:11.92 oz
- Offset:8 mm
- Upper:Lightweight mesh with textured overlays
- Midfoot support:Leather saddle
- Midsole:Charged Cushioning
- Outsole:Rubber with flex grooves
- Closure:Lace-up
- Origin:Made in the USA or imported
Our verdict“I recommend the Commit Trainer 4 for its breathable, flexible design and specified weight, though the Commit 5 is my stronger all-around pick.”

How We Picked
I ranked these shoes around the needs implied by men’s training shoes: a secure-feeling upper, cushioning for repeated steps, and a rubber outsole suited to changes in direction. I gave particular weight to features that connect directly with those needs, such as flex grooves, outsole traction patterns, midfoot overlays, and cushioning placement. The Commit Trainer 5 leads because its listed full-length Charged Cushioning and flex grooves make it the most clearly specified all-around training choice in this group.
I also separated different kinds of usefulness rather than treating every model as interchangeable. The New Balance 608 V5 gets credit for its structured suede upper, heel cushioning, and slip-resistant outsole, but its leather construction may take time to break in. The Charged Edge models offer a comfort-oriented sockliner and traction pattern for pivots; the 4E version earns a distinct place because width is a practical fit requirement, not a minor feature. The Commit Trainer 4 remains a sensible cushioned option, though its listed weight and older listed offset make the newer Commit 5 a stronger general recommendation on paper.
The product information does not include details such as individual fit measurements, durability testing, or workout-specific performance results. I avoid filling those gaps with assumptions. Instead, I compare the supplied construction and specs, note real tradeoffs, and recommend each shoe only for the buyer its listed features best support.
| training shoes for men | Upper | Midsole | Outsole | Origin |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Under Armour Charged Commit Tr | Breathable mesh with leather overlays | Full-length Charged Cushioning | Full rubber with side wrap | Imported |
| New Balance Men’s 608 V5 Casua | Suede leather | EVA foam | Rubber; slip-resistant | Imported |
| Under Armour Men’s Charged Edg | Breathable mesh with leather and synthetic overlays | Charged Cushioning compression-molded foam | Full rubber with pivot and traction pattern | Imported |
| Under Armour Men’s Charged Edg | Breathable mesh with leather and synthetic overlays | Charged Cushioning | Full rubber with strategic traction patterns | Imported |
| Under Armour Men’s Charged Com | Lightweight mesh with textured overlays | Charged Cushioning | Rubber with flex grooves | Made in the USA or imported |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Training Shoes For Men
I would start with the workout and fit problem you need the shoe to solve. These models share rubber outsoles and cushioning, but their uppers, fit details, and cushioning descriptions point to different priorities.
Match the build to your training
For varied general gym sessions, the Charged Commit Trainer 5 is the easiest starting point: its listing specifies full-length cushioning, flex grooves, and a rubber outsole. If you prefer a more structured shoe for workouts alongside walking or standing, the New Balance 608 V5 pairs a suede upper with heel cushioning and a slip-resistant outsole. The Charged Edge is the clearest match when the listed pivot and traction pattern aligns with the movement you do. None of these descriptions establishes a single shoe as suitable for every sport or lifting style, so favor the construction that fits your actual routine.
Compare cushioning and offset carefully
Charged Cushioning appears in both Commit models and the Charged Edge, while the 608 V5 specifies an ABZORB heel crash pad plus EVA foam. Those labels describe different setups; they do not provide a direct measurement of softness or support. The Commit 5 lists a 6 mm offset and the Commit 4 lists 8 mm. I would treat that as a useful point of comparison, not a promise that one will feel better for every person. If you have strong preferences about heel-to-toe offset or midsole feel, check the fit and product details before choosing.
Choose upper structure versus airflow
The mesh uppers on the Commit and Charged Edge models are the obvious choices if you want a more breathable construction. Their overlays add support and durability, with the Commit 4 specifically naming a leather midfoot saddle. The 608 V5’s suede leather build is more substantial and may appeal to someone who wants a supportive everyday cross trainer, but its listing warns that the upper may need break-in time. Think about how much structure you like around the foot, rather than choosing by material name alone.
Treat width as a first-order fit feature
Only one listing explicitly states a width: the Charged Edge in 4E extra wide. That makes it the most straightforward choice for a shopper who already knows standard-width shoes feel too narrow. The standard Charged Edge and other models do not include a width specification in the supplied details, so I would not assume they have the same roomy fit. If you are between widths or need a particular fit through the forefoot, confirm the exact sizing options and return terms before buying.
Read the missing specifications as part of the decision
Not every listing supplies the same amount of information. The Commit 4 names its weight, while the Commit 5 gives a specific offset and full-length midsole description. Neither Charged Edge listing supplies a weight or offset in the provided specs. This does not establish a performance flaw, but it limits direct comparison. I would put more weight on the details that matter most to you—such as fit, outsole traction, or stated cushioning—and avoid treating unspecified features as confirmed advantages.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which shoe is the best all-around training pick in this group?
I rank the Under Armour Charged Commit Trainer 5 first for general training because its listing combines full-length Charged Cushioning, a breathable upper with leather overlays, flex grooves, and a full rubber outsole. It is not the best fit for every buyer: men who need 4E sizing should look at the wide Charged Edge listing, while shoppers who prefer a structured suede upper may favor the New Balance 608 V5.
Which option is made for extra-wide feet?
The Under Armour Charged Edge listing with 4E extra-wide sizing is the only shoe in this roundup with a specific wide-width designation. The other listings do not state a width in the supplied product details, so buyers who need extra room should verify sizing availability rather than assume a standard listing offers the same fit.
How do the Charged Commit Trainer 4 and 5 differ?
The Commit Trainer 5 lists a 6 mm offset and full-length Charged Cushioning, along with a rubber outsole that has flex grooves and a side wrap. The Commit Trainer 4 lists an 8 mm offset, a weight of 11.92 oz, and a leather midfoot saddle. I rank the 5 higher as an all-around choice, while the 4 may suit shoppers who value its stated weight and support detail.
Is the New Balance 608 V5 a good choice for everyday wear as well as workouts?
Its suede leather upper, ABZORB heel cushioning, EVA foam midsole, and slip-resistant outsole make the 608 V5 a plausible option for buyers splitting time between moderate workouts and daily wear. The upper is more structured than the mesh models and may need a break-in period, so it is less suited to someone who wants a flexible, airy feel from the start.
Which shoe has the clearest outsole details for pivots and traction?
The Charged Edge listings specifically describe a full rubber outsole with strategic traction for pivots and grip. The Commit models also list rubber outsoles and flex grooves, while the New Balance 608 V5 is described as slip-resistant. These descriptions help compare intended features, but they do not provide a direct test of traction on every surface.
Conclusion
For one shoe to cover general gym training, I would start with the Charged Commit Trainer 5 for its full-length cushioning and flexible rubber outsole. Choose the New Balance 608 V5 if you prefer a more structured shoe for workouts and everyday wear and are comfortable allowing time for the suede upper to break in. If fit is the deciding factor, the 4E Charged Edge is the clear pick for extra-wide sizing; the standard Charged Edge makes more sense for shoppers drawn to its pivot-oriented traction without a stated wide-width need. The Commit Trainer 4 remains an option if its leather midfoot saddle and listed weight appeal, but the Commit 5 is my stronger all-round recommendation.








